Ethical Governance of AI in International Relations: Shifting Power Dynamics and India's Role
Contents4
The Hindu - Opinion · 22 Jun 2026 · 2 min read
Prelims · International relations Mains · GS2 International relations High relevance
The global order is witnessing a shift towards realist power politics driven by AI, economic coercion, and technological dominance, raising ethical concerns about statecraft and necessitating India's leadership in establishing ethical frameworks.
Key points
Realpolitik in AI Era: Global power dynamics are increasingly defined by technological dominance, economic coercion, and military deterrence, with diminishing emphasis on ethical considerations.
Venezuela and Cuba: These cases illustrate how economic sanctions and strategic isolation are used to influence sovereign states, raising questions about the ethical limits of intervention.
Technological Containment: The weaponization of supply chains and AI-driven surveillance highlights the transactional nature of modern international relations.
Historical Context: The 20th century saw the US providing a normative framework (Wilson's Fourteen Points, Roosevelt's Four Freedoms), emphasizing moral purpose in power.
Gandhi and Mandela: Demonstrated that ethical legitimacy, not material power, can drive political transformation, a contrast to current trends.
[GS3-Science and Technology] AI's integration into surveillance, cyber operations, and autonomous weapons risks moral detachment, with human judgment being replaced by algorithmic efficiency.
[GS2-International Relations] Japan's Free and Open Indo-Pacific approach links security with technology governance, offering a model for India-Japan cooperation on ethical AI rules.
Institutional Weakening: Declining trust in political institutions and organized religion has created a vacuum in public morality, despite persistent societal demands for justice.
India's Civilizational Role: India's democratic ethos and historical depth position it to lead in rethinking ethical foundations of global order amid AI and geopolitical fragmentation.
Way Forward: India should advocate for international norms on AI ethics, establish bilateral tech governance frameworks with Japan, and integrate ethical considerations into its foreign policy to counterbalance realist power politics.
Key terms
- Realpolitik
- A pragmatic approach to politics, prioritizing practical outcomes over ideological or ethical considerations. In UPSC context, it explains shifts in international relations where states prioritize strategic gains, often at the expense of normative frameworks.
- Fourteen Points
- Woodrow Wilson's 1918 principles for post-WWI peace, including national self-determination and open diplomacy. Relevant for GS2 as it shaped modern international institutions like the League of Nations and UN.
- Free and Open Indo-Pacific (FOIP)
- Japan's strategic framework emphasizing rule-based order, connectivity, and maritime security in the Indo-Pacific. For UPSC, it highlights evolving regional architectures like the Quad and India's strategic partnerships.
- Algorithmic Efficiency
- The use of AI to optimize decision-making in governance and military operations. In GS3, this raises ethical concerns about accountability and human oversight in critical domains like defense and surveillance.
Practice question
Critically analyze the ethical challenges posed by the integration of AI into international relations, with a focus on shifting power dynamics. How can India play a leadership role in establishing ethical frameworks in this context? (250 words, 15 marks)
GS2 15 marks 250 words Mains
Key terms to include: Realpolitik Fourteen Points Free and Open Indo-Pacific (FOIP) Algorithmic Efficiency Ethical Legitimacy Technological Containment Moral Detachment Normative Frameworks
Answer framework
Introduction
Briefly introduce the rise of AI in international relations and its ethical implications, highlighting the shift towards realist power politics.
Ethical Challenges of AI in International Relations
Diminishing ethical considerations in favor of technological dominance and economic coercion (Realpolitik).
Weaponization of AI in surveillance, cyber operations, and autonomous weapons leading to moral detachment.
Transactional nature of modern international relations, as seen in cases like Venezuela and Cuba.
Shifting Power Dynamics
Decline of normative frameworks like Wilson's Fourteen Points and Roosevelt's Four Freedoms.
Growing reliance on algorithmic efficiency over human judgment in statecraft.
Weakening of political and religious institutions, creating a vacuum in public morality.
India's Potential Leadership Role
Leveraging India's democratic ethos and historical depth to advocate for ethical AI norms.
Collaborating with partners like Japan under frameworks such as the Free and Open Indo-Pacific (FOIP).
Integrating ethical considerations into foreign policy to counterbalance realist power politics.
Conclusion
Emphasize the need for a balanced approach where India champions ethical frameworks while navigating the complexities of AI-driven international relations.
Fact check
All facts verified