Which one of the following best defines the term 'State'?
Contents11
- AA community of persons permanently occupying a definite territory independent of external control and possessing an organized government
- BA politically organized people of a definite territory and possessing an authority to govern them, maintain law and order, protect their natural rights and safeguard their means of sustenance
- CA number of persons who have been living in a definite territory for a very long time with their own culture, tradition and government
- DA society permanently living in a definite territory with a central authority, an executive responsible to the central authority and an independent judiciary
Show answer
Answer: (A) A community of persons permanently occupying a definite territory independent of external control and possessing an organized government
A 'State' in political science has four essential elements:
(1) People — a permanent community of persons;
(2) Territory — a defined geographical area;
(3) Government — organized political authority;
(4) Sovereignty — independence from external control.
Option (a) covers all four:
- 'community of persons' (people),
- 'permanently occupying a definite territory' (territory),
- 'possessing an organized government' (government),
- and 'independent of external control' (sovereignty).
Other options either miss elements or add features of specific government types, not the definition of a state.
Answer: (a).
The definition of 'State' requires exactly four elements: people, territory, government, and sovereignty (independence from external control).
This foundational concept determines what qualifies as a state in international law and helps understand issues like recognition of new nations, territorial disputes, and sovereignty claims.
UPSC tests whether students can distinguish between the basic definition of a state versus specific types of government systems or cultural communities.
State Definition in Political Science
Indian Polity State community of persons definite territory organized government external control
State Definition: Four Essential Elements & UPSC Traps
A State has four essential elements: People, Territory, Government, and Sovereignty
People = permanent community (not temporary visitors)
Territory = defined geographical area with boundaries
Government = organized political authority to rule
Sovereignty = independence from external control
What is a State?
In political science, a 'State' is not just any government or country. It has a precise definition with four mandatory elements that must all be present. This classical definition helps distinguish states from other political entities like colonies, territories, or tribal groups.
Four Elements of State
Element | Definition | Key Feature | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
People | Permanent community of persons | Must be permanent, not temporary | Citizens & residents living there continuously |
Territory | Definite geographical area | Must have defined boundaries | Land, water bodies, airspace within borders |
Government | Organized political authority | Must be organized system of rule | Executive, legislature, judiciary working together |
Sovereignty | Independence from external control | Must be free from external dominance | Makes own laws without foreign interference |
Why Option A is Correct
Option A covers all four elements perfectly:
'Community of persons' = People element
'Permanently occupying' = Permanent population requirement
'Definite territory' = Territory element
'Organized government' = Government element
'Independent of external control' = Sovereignty element
Trap: Option B adds 'natural rights' and 'means of sustenance' — these are government functions, not state definition elements
Trap: Option C mentions 'very long time' and 'culture, tradition' — time duration and culture are not essential elements of a state
Trap: Option D specifies 'executive responsible to central authority' and 'independent judiciary' — these describe specific government types, not the basic state definition
Memory Aid: Remember PTGS — People, Territory, Government, Sovereignty
Sovereignty in Political Theory
Indian Polity sovereignty independent external control
Sovereignty: Types & Constitutional Relevance
Sovereignty means supreme authority within territory and independence from external control
Indian Constitution declares India a 'Sovereign' republic in the Preamble
Internal Sovereignty = supreme power within the state
External Sovereignty = independence from foreign control
Understanding Sovereignty
Sovereignty is the most crucial element that separates a state from colonies, protectorates, or dependent territories. It means the state has the final say in its internal affairs and is not subordinate to any external power.
Types of Sovereignty
Type | Meaning | Examples | Importance |
|---|---|---|---|
Internal Sovereignty | Supreme authority within state boundaries | Power to make laws, collect taxes, maintain order | No rival authority inside the state |
External Sovereignty | Independence from foreign control | Not a colony, protectorate, or dependency | Free to conduct foreign relations |
Legal Sovereignty | Ultimate legal authority | Parliament/Constitution as highest law | All other laws derive from this |
Popular Sovereignty | Authority comes from the people | Democratic elections, constitutional government | Legitimacy based on popular will |
Sovereignty in Indian Context
The Preamble declares India a 'Sovereign' republic, meaning:
Internal: Parliament is the supreme law-making body
External: India is not subordinate to any foreign power (unlike colonial period)
Popular: Authority comes from 'We, the People of India'
Trap: Don't confuse sovereignty with autonomy — autonomous regions have self-rule but are not sovereign
Trap: Globalization limits practical sovereignty but doesn't eliminate legal sovereignty
Note: Even federal states have divisible internal sovereignty between center and states, but indivisible external sovereignty
State vs Government vs Nation
Indian Polity
State vs Government vs Nation: Key Distinctions
State = permanent entity with four elements (People, Territory, Government, Sovereignty)
Government = temporary institution that runs the state
Nation = people with shared culture, language, ethnicity
Nation-State = when nation and state boundaries coincide
State vs Government vs Nation
Entity | Definition | Duration | Example | Key Feature |
|---|---|---|---|---|
State | Political entity with 4 elements | Permanent (continues despite government changes) | India as a state since 1947 | Has sovereignty, territory, people, government |
Government | Institution that runs the state | Temporary (changes with elections) | BJP govt, Congress govt | Exercises state power for limited period |
Nation | People with shared identity | Cultural continuity across time | Kurdish nation (spread across states) | Shared language, culture, ethnicity, history |
Nation-State | Nation and state boundaries match | Depends on political arrangements | Japan (Japanese nation = Japanese state) | Cultural unity + political unity |
Political Entities Classification
# Political Entities
## Based on Territory
- State (sovereign territory)
- Colony (dependent territory)
- Protectorate (limited sovereignty)
## Based on Culture
- Nation (shared culture)
- Ethnic group (shared ancestry)
- Linguistic community
## Based on Government
- Democracy
- Monarchy
- Authoritarian
- Federal
- UnitaryTrap: State ≠ Government — India (state) remains same whether ruled by Congress or BJP (government)
Trap: Nation ≠ State — Kurdish nation exists without a Kurdish state; Switzerland has multiple nations in one state
Trap: Don't use 'country' in exam answers — use precise terms like 'state', 'nation', or 'nation-state'
Memory: State = political, Nation = cultural, Government = institutional